By Alex Carlson: Understanding Top Leases in Oil and Gas

If you have received an offer to sign a top lease covering your mineral rights, it generally means another oil and gas company is interested in your property, even though your minerals are already under lease. While this can be a positive sign that your acreage is desirable, a top lease can also create significant legal and financial issues that every mineral owner should understand before signing.

What Is a Top Lease?

A top lease is an oil and gas lease that is signed while an existing lease (sometimes called the base lease or bottom lease) is still in effect. Unlike a standard lease, a top lease does not become effective immediately. Instead, it is designed to take effect only if the existing lease expires or terminates. A top lease may be taken by either the current lessee or a third party that is not a party to, or successor to, the original lease.   

For example, a mineral owner signed a five-year lease with Company A in 2022. As the end of that five-year primary term approaches, Company B believes Company A may not drill a well or otherwise maintain the lease. Rather than waiting to determine whether the lease expires, Company B offers the mineral owner a top lease that automatically becomes effective if Company A’s lease expires.  This arrangement is commonly referred to as a three-party top lease.

Alternatively, as the five-year lease with Company A is coming to an end, Company A may reach out to the mineral owner and offer a top lease on the existing acreage.  The purpose is to preserve its leasehold position if it is not prepared to commence drilling before the original lease expires. This is considered a two-party top lease.

Top leases generally arise in areas where leasing activity is competitive and companies are trying to secure future drilling opportunities before they become available.

Why Would an Oil and Gas Company Use a Top Lease?

From an operator’s perspective, a top lease is a strategic business tool.  Instead of waiting until a lease expires, and potentially competing with multiple companies afterward, a company can secure future leasing rights in advance. If the existing lease terminates, the top lessee is already positioned to begin development.

Companies may pursue top leases for several reasons, including:

  • Securing future drilling opportunities in highly competitive areas
  • Protecting acreage adjacent to existing operations
  • Planning long-term development programs
  • Preventing competitors from acquiring valuable mineral rights

A top lease is a calculated investment. The company pays a lease bonus today for rights it may never if the existing lease remains in effect.

Why Would a Mineral Owner Sign a Top Lease?

A top lease can also benefit a mineral owner under the right circumstances. If an existing lease appears unlikely to continue beyond its primary term, a top lease may allow the owner to secure more favorable economic terms.

Potential advantages include:

  • A higher lease bonus
  • Increased royalty rates
  • Better lease provisions than those contained in the existing lease
  • The opportunity to work with a different operator who may have stronger development plans

Receiving a top lease offer may also indicate that multiple companies believe the minerals have significant development potential.  However, the existence of a top lease offer does not necessarily mean the current lease will expire. Many leases continue beyond their primary term because production has begun or because other lease provisions extend the lease. That uncertainty is one of the biggest reasons top leases require careful review.

Potential Issues and Pitfalls of Top Leases

Although top leases can create opportunities, they also introduce legal risks for both operators and mineral owners.

Uncertainty About Whether the Existing Lease Has Actually Ended

One of the most common disputes is determining whether the base lease truly expired. An oil and gas lease may continue beyond its stated primary term if the operator:

  • Commenced drilling operations before expiration
  • Maintained production
  • Properly paid shut-in royalties
  • Extended the lease under other provisions contained in the lease agreement

If the original lease remains valid, the top lease may never become effective. Determining whether a lease has terminated is often a fact-intensive legal question.

Litigation Between Competing Lessees

Top leasing frequently results in disputes between the holder of the original lease and the company holding the top lease.

If both companies believe they possess valid lease rights, litigation may follow to determine who owns the leasehold interest. Those disputes can delay drilling, increase costs, and create uncertainty for everyone involved.

Novation Risks

One of the more subtle legal concerns is the doctrine of novation.  A novation occurs when a new agreement replaces an existing contract. In the context of top leasing, if the top lease is drafted improperly or becomes effective in a way that suggests the parties intended to replace the existing lease rather than simply create a future interest, a court could conclude that the original lease has been extinguished.

This can produce unintended consequences, including:

  • Loss of valuable rights under the original lease
  • Termination of contractual protection
  • Disputes over overriding royalty interests
  • Unexpected title complications

Because of this possibility, attorneys often recommend carefully drafting top leases to make clear that they are contingent upon the termination of the existing lease and are not intended to replace it prematurely.

Existing Contract Obligations

The original lease may be connected to other agreements, such as gas purchase contracts or overriding royalty interests.

If the original lessee later attempts to restructure its leasehold through a new lease arrangement, questions may arise about whether those obligations continue or terminate. These issues can become highly fact-specific and may ultimately require judicial resolution.

What Should Mineral Owners Look for Before Signing a Top Lease?

Because every lease is different, mineral owners should avoid assuming that a top lease is automatically a better deal. Before signing, consider the following:

Review Your Existing Lease

The first step is to understand exactly what rights are already in place. Questions to ask include:

  • When does the primary term expire?
  • Has drilling begun?
  • Is the lease currently producing?
  • Are there shut-in royalty or continuous operations provisions?
  • Could the lease already be extended into its secondary term?
  • Does the bottom lease have a right of first refusal provision?

The answers will help determine whether the top lease is ever likely to become effective.

Compare the Financial Terms

Many top leases offer:

  • Large signing bonuses
  • Higher royalty percentages
  • More favorable lease provisions

However, higher compensation alone does not necessarily make a top lease the better business decision if the existing lease is unlikely to expire.

Evaluate the Reputation of the Company

Not every company pursuing top leases intends to develop the mineral interests it acquires.

Research the operator’s experience, financial strength, and development history. A company with a proven record of drilling and production may offer greater long-term value than one primarily acquiring speculative lease positions.

Understand When the Top Lease Takes Effect

The lease should clearly state:

  • What event causes it to become effective
  • Whether it is contingent upon complete termination of the existing lease
  • How disputes regarding expiration of the original lease will be handled

Clear drafting helps reduce uncertainty if disagreements arise later.

Have the Lease Reviewed by an Oil and Gas Attorney

Top leases often involve issues that do not arise in ordinary leasing transactions. Because they can affect existing contractual rights and create title questions, having an experienced oil and gas attorney review the document before signing is often a worthwhile investment.

Final Thoughts

A top lease can present an excellent opportunity for both mineral owners and oil and gas companies. For operators, it secures future leasing opportunities in competitive areas. For mineral owners, it may provide stronger financial terms and additional negotiating leverage.

At the same time, top leases exist in the shadow of an existing lease, making them more legally complex than a traditional oil and gas lease. Questions surrounding lease expiration, competing lease rights, and novation can all affect whether a top lease ultimately provides the benefits both parties expect.

Before signing any top lease, mineral owners should seek qualified legal advice from an experienced oil and gas attorney to carefully review their existing lease, compare the proposed terms, and understand the conditions under which the top lease becomes effective. A careful review at the outset can help avoid costly disputes and ensure the agreement aligns with all parties’ long-term interests.

By Alex Carlson, Senior Attorney at KMD Law