By Bridgette Halley: From Probate to Production: How Estate Planning Decisions Affect Texas Mineral Ownership

For many Texas families, mineral interests are assets that quietly pass from one generation to the next. Unlike a home, bank account, or other personal property such as an automobile or prized card collection that may receive immediate attention following a loved one’s death, mineral interests can remain unnoticed for years or even decades until an oil and gas lease offer arrives, drilling begins, or an operator attempts to determine who should receive royalty payments.

It is often at this point families discover a problem because no transactions or payments regarding mineral interests will occur until ‘clear title’ has been determined. For example: a relative may have died without leaving a will or a will was never probated; a trust may have terminated years ago without a distribution deed from the trust to its beneficiaries; or an old deed contains unique language regarding the mineral estate that no one fully considered when preparing the family’s estate plan. Decisions made or left unmade during estate planning and administration of the estate can significantly affect the ownership and marketability of mineral interests years later.

Mineral Interests are Real Property

A mineral interest is an interest in real property and, like other real property, must be transferred from one owner to the next. Mineral interest transfers usually require recording thereof in the county where the minerals are located.

When a mineral owner dies, the family may understand that a parent left everything to the children, but the real property records may not clearly reflect what actually happened.  A landman or title attorney examining title years later for an oil and gas operator must determine: Was there a will? Was it admitted to probate? Who were the beneficiaries? Did any beneficiary subsequently die? Who are the beneficiaries of the deceased beneficiary? Was the property conveyed to or from a trust? Did the trust terminate? Were the necessary documents recorded in the county where the minerals are located?

Until those questions can be answered, an operator may be unable to confidently determine clear title, i.e., who is entitled to execute a lease or who receives royalties under a lease.

Common Estate Issues that Can Become Title Problems

Common estate-planning and administration issues can create complicated title problems later.

Failure to probate a will. A deceased relative created a will but the family decides there is no reason to probate the will because the deceased relative did not own very many assets. However, maybe the deceased relative was unaware of their ownership of any mineral interest. Years later a family member gets an unexpected knock at the door or letter in the mail from an operator offering to lease those interests. Now what?

Intestate Succession.  If a mineral interest owner dies without a will or dies having a will but that will was not probated, Texas intestate law determines who inherits the property. This law makes distinctions if the mineral interest was separate property or community property of the deceased or whether the deceased’s children were children of both the deceased and the surviving spouse, if any, or a prior spouse. As those heirs subsequently die, marry, divorce, or have children of their own, what began as a single mineral interest can become divided among numerous descendants. Determining ownership several generations later may require extensive heirship research and curative work.

Overreliance on Affidavits of Heirship. Affidavits of Heirship are frequently accepted in Texas title examination to establish who owns a deceased’s mineral interest when there is no will or a will has not been probated, but they are not a substitute for thoughtful estate planning. Their effectiveness depends upon the information provided, meeting certain statutory requirements, and being recorded for a length of time. An Affidavit prepared years after a death is more difficult when the individuals with firsthand knowledge of the family history are no longer available.

Trusts that are not properly administered. Mineral interests do not become property of a trust until the owners convey these assets to the trust. Likewise, when a trust terminates, mineral interests held by the trust must be distributed to the correct beneficiaries of the trust. The trust document, deeds, and distribution documents are all important when determining ownership.

Incomplete title or ambiguous conveyances. Mineral and royalty interests are particularly susceptible to problems created by fractional language, reservations, and exceptions. An estate plan may identify the intended beneficiary, but it cannot necessarily cure a gap in title or an ambiguity that already exists in an instrument included in the chain of title.

Recent Texas Cases Illustrate Why These Issues Still Matter

Recent Texas appellate decisions demonstrate that these are not simply hypothetical concerns.

In Gill v. Baumgarten, No. 04-25-00517-CV, 2026 WL 2041683 (Tex. App.—San Antonio July 15, 2026, no pet. h.) the underlying dispute involved valuable Webb County mineral interests associated with a testamentary trust that had been terminated decades earlier. The parties disputed, among other things, whether the trust could be revived and resume ownership of the mineral interests and royalties. Although the appellate decision focused on a jurisdictional issue, the underlying controversy illustrates how questions surrounding the administration or termination of a trust can have consequences decades later when valuable mineral production is involved.

A recent deed construction case provides another cautionary lesson. In B.H.C.H. Mineral, Ltd. v. Needmore Minerals, LLP, No. 04-24-00382-CV, 2026 WL 1430702 (Tex. App.—San Antonio May 20, 2026, pet. filed) the San Antonio Court of Appeals considered reservation language contained in a 1937 deed that had long been treated as creating a fixed 1/32 non-participating royalty interest. The court concluded, however, that the deed reserved a 1/32 non-executive mineral interest that included a floating royalty interest tied to the royalty provided in future leases. The dispute demonstrates how language written generations ago can continue to determine the economic value of property inherited by today’s mineral owners.

What generations of owners believe they inherited or how an interest has been treated historically may not necessarily reflect what the original deed legally created. Together, Gill and Needmore demonstrate that effective planning for mineral interests requires attention to both sides of the ownership equation: a) how the interest passes from one generation to the next and b) what interest the family actually owns in the first place.

Practical Steps for Texas Mineral Owners

Many future title problems can be reduced through careful planning.

** Make sure your estate planning attorney is made aware of all mineral interests you own, including interests that are producing or nonproducing. An interest that produces little or no income currently may become more valuable if development occurs years later.

    ** Maintain copies of deeds, leases, division orders, probate records, trust documents, and other records concerning your mineral interests. Confirm where your interests are located and how those interests are titled currently.

    ** If an estate plan calls for mineral interests to be held in trust or distributed from the trust, complete the appropriate conveyances.

    ** Consider addressing potential title problems before you receive a lease offer or learn that royalty or other payments are being held pending a resolution of a title issue. Curative work is less stressful when you are not waiting for royalty proceeds to be released.

    Planning Today Can Prevent Title Problems Tomorrow

    Mineral interests often outlive the people who acquired them. An estate planning decision made today may determine whether children or grandchildren encounter a straightforward transfer or a complicated title problem years from now. Effective planning involves more than deciding who will ultimately receive the property; it also helps ensure that ownership can be established when the time comes to lease, sell, develop, or receive royalties from that property.

    By Bridgette Halley, Senior Attorney at KMD Law